What Do I Deem a Good Manga? - Addison Wright

 When trying to think of a blog post, I was stuck on what I should write about. Then, I realized that so many of my posts have been about mangas and ranking them. However, I never even stated what I deem a "good" manga! This post will basically be skimming my brain to see how it works!

I will talk about Waiting for Spring by Anashin, since I believe this manga is one of the best I have ever read. I think many things go into being a good book, let alone being a good manga. As someone who is very picky about what she reads, my brain goes through various "checklists" that send off signals, telling me I will enjoy it.

First, we have the first thing that most people notice: art style. To put it simply, if someone doesn't have a good art style, I will not enjoy it, no matter how many other boxes they check. If it has a bad art style, I will refuse to read it. An example of this is Classmates by Asumiko Nakamura. On the other side of the spectrum, you have Waiting for Spring. The art style is absolutely flawless and is overall one of the best art styles I have seen for something like this.

Next, I look for the storyline. If the manga seems interesting, I will read it. I feel like this one is very self-explanatory and doesn't need an example.

Finally, I look for text bubbles. If there are too many text bubbles on one page, it makes it confusing and difficult to read and honestly takes all the fun out of reading them. Reading them is supposed to be a calming activity, but when I read one that continuously rambles on for pages at a time, I lose interest. One manga that is guilty of this is Ouran High School Host Club. 

Overall, these are the three things that I look for whenever I am doing a review of a manga. I hope this helps enter that side of my brain!

Comments

  1. Hi Addison! It's so interesting to see what makes a good manga in your opinion. If i ever check out any mangas, I will keep these guidelines in mind. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Addison, as a manga reader myself, I really relate to how you determine what a good manga is. I will make sure to try waiting for spring!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Addison, I totally agree that art style is really important and has a lot of variation in manga. I know everyone has different tastes so I'm curious as to what yours is - what makes "Waiting for Spring" seem "flawless" to you? I searched it up so I could see some images, is it maybe the softness of it? Or the color scheme? I think this manga's art looks really nice too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Charlotte! You pretty much summed up my thinking haha! I definitely look for the softness in the art; no harsh lines/shading. I also look for proportionate body parts (like, the eyes being the right size for the face😭)

      Delete
  4. Hello, Addison. Quite frankly I have never touched a manga in my life, in fact the term is pretty new to me. I'll take into consideration what you deem as a worth-while manga if I ever decide to read one myself.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Addison, as a Manga fan, I'm excited to check out "Waiting for Spring." I took a brief look and the art style is indeed amazing. Nice blog!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Addison! I've never been able to enjoy a manga (despite the amount of times I've tried to enjoy it/people recommending it to me), so your idea's of a good manga really help me! I'll try to read manga in the near future!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

An Overview of the Album "Who Really Cares" by TV Girl by Addison Wright (Pt. 1/2)

A review of Barron's AP Computer Science A prep book - DJ

An Overview of the album "Who Really Cares" by TV Girl by Addison Wright (Pt. 2/2)